Healthcare Policy, Market Access, Research & Development

Zytiga, the Lockerbie Bomber, and Access to Drugs for Advanced Prostate Cancers

Zytiga, the Lockerbie Bomber, and Access to Drugs for Advanced Prostate CancersThe death of the Lockerbie bomber, Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi, from metastatic prostate cancer, has thrust Johnson & Johnson’s prostate cancer drug Zytiga (abiraterone acetate) into the spotlight. In August 2009, Al- Megrahi, diagnosed with metastatic prostate cancer and thought only to have a few months to live, was released from Scotland on compassionate grounds, only to live out more than two years of life in Libya. The extra lease on life has been attributed to treatment with Zytiga, placing the drug in a rather precarious position and undoubtedly causing J&J to wonder if this news should be celebrated or ignored.

How can a prognosis be so far off? It’s part and parcel of cancer treatment. As much as technology has advanced and personalised therapy has become mainstream, how a therapy will affect each individual patient is still often a shot in the dark. Uncertainty prevails.

Al-Megrahi’s situation harkens back to the FDA’s revocation of Avastin’s metastatic breast cancer label in the US based on data which showed that it did not improve overall survival and that, ultimately, the risks outweighed the benefits. While the agency was making the tough decision they held a two-day public hearing, during which many women presented personal anecdotes arguing that Avastin had saved their lives. How could the government revoke approval for a drug that is keeping me alive, the sentiment went? But how do you account for all those for whom the treatment doesn’t provide any added benefit, and sometimes results in harsh, and quality of life lowering, side effects? These questions have plagued regulators and payors and are at the heart of many governments’ healthcare policies.

The United Kingdom’s NICE is currently grappling with this debate vis a vis Zytiga. NICE initially rejected the drug and the Al-Megrahi case acted as lightening rod for intense criticism surrounding NICE’s decision. However, just days before Al-Megrahi’s death, NICE made a u-turn and has now recommended the drug after the manufacturer provided an undisclosed price discount through a revised patient access scheme, quieting dissenters, at least for the time being.

Zytiga had less controversial developments keeping it in the public eye. ASCO has published approximately 4500 abstracts online which will be presented next week at its annual meeting. A Zytiga study was among the five studies, which ASCO chose to highlight from the milieu of abstracts. The Phase II study demonstrated that pre-surgical treatment with Zytiga in localized, high-risk prostate cancer, eliminated, or virtually eliminated cancer in 58 or one-third of the treated men. Clearly these are encouraging results. And yet, success won’t be certain until more mature study results, such as overall survival data, comes to fruition. But fortunately for those familiar with the whims of cancer treatments and drugs, uncertainty is nothing new.

About Sophia Walker

Sophia Walker manages the IHS Life Sciences Emerging Markets team and runs the oncology service. She has an extensive background in oncology clinical trials, as well as expertise in market access, pricing and reimbursement and healthcare development in emerging markets.

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Download extract from IHS Flexible Pricing strategies multi client study
Drug Price Erosion Multi Client Study extract download

About This Blog

In this blog, our experts share regular insights on the global life sciences industry. Join us as we look at issues in healthcare policy, market access, pricing and reimbursement and R&D. Comments are welcome!
40 countries covered. Download a sample chapter on Brazil
Download a complimentary white paper on market-access risk ratings
Download a sample of the primary research and analysis on French P&R reform

Follow IHS Life Sciences on Twitter

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 306 other followers